WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Michigan ranked last with 34% in Napa Legal Institute’s 2026 Faith and Freedom Index, while Alabama led the country with 80%.
  • DeVito cited burdensome nondiscrimination rules, inadequate religious exemptions and financial reporting requirements as obstacles for religious nonprofits.
  • New York scored higher overall than Republican led North Dakota, South Carolina and Tennessee, complicating conventional partisan expectations.
  • Florida clarified nonprofit governance rules, while Massachusetts and Rhode Island raised thresholds that trigger mandatory independent audits.

Michigan ranked last nationwide for legal protections affecting religious nonprofits in Napa Legal Institute’s 2026 Faith and Freedom Index, while Alabama claimed the top position. The report, obtained by Fox News Digital, revealed sharp and sometimes unexpected differences among states led by Republicans and Democrats.

Released Monday, the index evaluates laws in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. It examines the legal environment facing religious organizations, including churches, religious schools, pregnancy resource centers and homeless shelters.

Michigan received an overall score of just 34%, the lowest in the country. Washington followed at 38%, while Massachusetts scored 41%, placing those states at the bottom of the new rankings.

Warning: Account balances and purchasing power no longer tell the same story. Know in 2 minutes if your retirement is working for you.

Napa Legal senior counsel Frank DeVito attributed Michigan’s low score to burdensome nondiscrimination requirements, weak religious exemptions and regulatory obstacles affecting religious organizations. He said those rules can create conflicts for Catholic schools and other religious institutions.

According to DeVito, religious institutions can face difficulty when attempting to make hiring and admissions decisions that align with their beliefs. Financial reporting requirements can also impose substantial costs on religious nonprofits, potentially pulling resources away from education, charitable services and aid for vulnerable communities.

Alabama stood at the opposite end of the index with a score of 80%. Kansas ranked next at 76%, followed by Indiana at 75% and Texas at 71%.

The report also produced results that did not fit neatly along conventional partisan lines. New York, which is led by Democrats, scored higher overall than the Republican led states of North Dakota, South Carolina and Tennessee.

FREE Gun Law Map: Laws Don't Pause During Social Unrest

Should Election Day be a federal holiday?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from BoredTrashPanda.com, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Some traditionally conservative states also trailed states led by Democrats in particular categories of legal protection. Those findings showed that party control alone did not determine how a state performed across every area examined by the index.

DeVito said New York offers stronger exemptions from “nondiscrimination” laws in employment and public programming than Tennessee. He also cited a New York state court ruling that found the state constitution provides greater protections for the free exercise of religion than the federal First Amendment.

According to Napa Legal, state laws can shape how religious organizations operate, apart from decisions by the Supreme Court or legislation enacted by Congress. The institute also reported that several states have strengthened protections for religious nonprofits in recent years.

Florida lawmakers updated the state’s nonprofit corporation laws to clarify that directors of religious organizations may seek guidance from religious leaders when making decisions involving matters of faith. Those leaders can include priests, ministers and rabbis.

Massachusetts and Rhode Island eased certain financial reporting requirements for nonprofits. Massachusetts increased the annual revenue threshold requiring an independent audit for nonprofits raising funds in the state from $200,000 to $500,000, while Rhode Island doubled its threshold from $500,000 to $1 million.

DeVito argued that lawmakers should establish durable legal protections because churches and religious organizations perform essential work. “For policymakers and government leaders, it's really important to put these laws on the books because the church, the religious organizations do needed work,” DeVito said.

“They educate children often in poor and disadvantaged circumstances. They feed the hungry, they help the most vulnerable people in society. They do something with the level of love and attention that the government never can.”

“We need religious organizations to thrive,” he continued. “If we are not attentive to the laws being such that these organizations can just do their work rather than spend their time and their money and their resources on administrative burdens that I think are frankly not necessary or fighting lawsuits over, you know, religious liberty issues that they shouldn't have to fight.”

DeVito warned that regulations and expensive legal disputes can divert time and resources from the missions of religious organizations, ultimately harming society. He urged lawmakers in both parties to pursue stronger religious liberty protections, including exemptions from certain nondiscrimination laws and tax requirements, despite possible political or budgetary challenges.

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of BoredTrashPanda.com. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.