WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • The NYC Democratic Socialists of America Choir sang new lyrics imagining a future without the NYPD.
  • The group promoted the familiar tune as adaptable for marches, picket lines and other socialist causes.
  • The September video went viral this week and was featured Thursday night on Fox News’ “Gutfeld.”
  • Online critics mocked the anti police message, emergency call implications and the choir’s apparent demographics.

The New York City Democratic Socialists of America Choir has become an online punchline after footage circulated of its members singing about a future without the NYPD. The performance paired a familiar melody with a distinctly socialist wish list, as reported by The New York Post.

The supposedly revolutionary choir used new lyrics set to the tune of “When the Saints Come Marching In.” The singers repeated, “When there’s no NYPD, oh when there’s no NYPD, how I want to be in that number, when there’s no NYPD.”

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Sing In Solidarity (@nycdsachoir)

The bouncy delivery quickly attracted ridicule as viewers questioned why the group seemed so proud of the performance. Footage of the choir spread widely online after initially appearing months earlier.

Warning: Account balances and purchasing power no longer tell the same story. Know in 2 minutes if your retirement is working for you.

The choir appeared to consist entirely of white singers, while critics also described its membership as mostly white and middle-aged women. That visual detail provided another target for commenters already mocking the group’s message.

Rather than treating the song as a one-time performance, the group promoted it as a useful tool for political activism. “This is a cheat code to get the movement singing,” the group enthusiastically claimed on the initial Instagram post.

The choir argued that the familiar melody made the number easy to use during political demonstrations. “It’s easily adaptable and people know the tune, making it great for marches and picket lines” and for when “the revolution comes,” the choir wrote.

The anti-NYPD refrain was only one version suggested by the group. The choir also offered several possible “zipper lines” that could be substituted into the song depending on the preferred socialist cause.

FREE Gun Law Map: Laws Don't Pause During Social Unrest

Should Election Day be a federal holiday?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from BoredTrashPanda.com, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Those alternatives included “when the people own their homes,” “when healthcare is free of charge,” and “when Palestine is free.” Together, the suggested lines presented the tune as an adaptable singalong for marches and picket lines.

Although the video was originally posted in September, it went viral this week and reached a much larger audience. The clip was even featured Thursday night on Fox News’ “Gutfeld,” where the choir’s performance received national attention.

Online critics immediately focused on the practical consequences of the group’s dream of a city without the NYPD. “Imagine all the stories we will have when all these people start getting robbed and attacked…Who are they going to call? Ghostbusters?” one X user jeered in response to the clip.

Another commenter argued that disrespecting police officers should have consequences when emergencies occur. “If you don’t want the NYPD and are disrespectful to the men and women who put their lives on the line for their community, then you don’t have the right to call 911 in case of an emergency,” the netizen wrote.

Others mocked the apparent gap between the choir’s revolutionary image and the everyday complaints they imagined its members making. “These are the people who call 311 multiple times a night because their neighbor is walking too loudly,” another commenter quipped.

The choir’s demographic appearance also became part of the online roasting. Commenters snarkily noted that the supposedly revolutionary group appeared to be composed largely of white, middle-aged women.

One response turned that observation into a joke about the singers’ home lives. “This is crazy! If they are all there, who’s at home feeding all their cats??” one snark wrote.

The group had pitched the song as a simple way to get activists singing together, emphasizing that people already knew the tune. Instead, the cheerful call for a future without the NYPD became the feature that propelled the months-old video into a fresh viral spectacle.

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of BoredTrashPanda.com. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.