WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Warren is trying to stop GM from proceeding with a $20 billion stock buyback plan.
  • Warren, Schumer, and Wyden introduced legislation proposing to quadruple the tax on stock buybacks.
  • GM says it has reinvested more than $100 billion in its business, factories, products, and employees since 2020.
  • GM argues the buyback demonstrates confidence in its ability to fund growth while returning capital to shareholders.

Senator Elizabeth Warren, the Massachusetts Democrat set to take over as chairman of the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, is trying to stop General Motors from proceeding with a $20 billion stock buyback plan.

In a letter to GM CEO Mary Barra, Warren complained that the buyback would "enrich … shareholders" and "prioritize investor profits," according to Bloomberg News. Of course, prioritizing investors is generally what corporate management is expected to do.

Warren has repeatedly voiced concern about the federal deficit while also favoring increased federal spending. If longtime GM shareholders sell their stock, they will have to pay capital gains tax, potentially producing more revenue for Washington politicians to spend.

Yet that prospective tax revenue apparently has not eased Warren’s concern that shareholders might profit. Her objection puts her squarely against investors who own the company and stand to benefit from its success.

Warning: Account balances and purchasing power no longer tell the same story. Know in 2 minutes if your retirement is working for you.

Warren appears to have found common cause with incoming Michigan senator Abdul El-Sayed, who campaigned with socialist Bernie Sanders. Immediately after GM announced the buyback on October 21, El-Sayed condemned the move in sweeping terms.

"GM just announced the biggest stock buyback in automotive industry history. Instead of investing in their workers or new product lines, GM executives are robbing from the future to pay themselves and their shareholders today. Stock buybacks should be illegal."

The anti buyback approach would leave corporate capital allocation in the hands of politicians rather than owners and managers. El-Sayed’s preferred policies would make the American auto industry and broader economy resemble Egypt, his ancestral home.

Egypt’s per capita gross domestic product is between $3,000 and $4,000 annually, where it has remained for about a decade. That is hardly an encouraging economic model for American companies or investors.

FREE Gun Law Map: Laws Don't Pause During Social Unrest

Should members of Congress have term limits?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from BoredTrashPanda.com, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Warren joined Democratic leader Chuck Schumer and Senate Finance Committee ranking Democrat Ron Wyden in June to introduce legislation proposing to quadruple the tax on stock buybacks. That proposal gives companies an incentive to complete buybacks before Democrats take over and raise the tax.

Schumer has campaigned against stock buybacks for years. He was first elected to Congress in 1980 after serving five years in the New York State assembly, and a Senate Democrats press release said, "Leader Schumer has been outspoken on the need to increase taxes for stock buybacks."

The same release said Schumer wrote an op-ed with Sanders in 2019 calling for limits on corporate buybacks. It also credited him with helping pass the Inflation Reduction Act in 2022, which created the original stock buyback tax.

Schumer later joined Wyden and Senator Bennett of Colorado in legislation that would increase the excise tax on stock buybacks by large oil and gas companies from 1% to 25%. Warren, Schumer, and Wyden now want the broader buyback tax quadrupled.

Buybacks allow shareholders to decide whether to sell their shares or continue holding them. Investors who see greater promise in super intelligence, space, nuclear energy, quantum computing, nanotechnology, or other companies can move their money, while shareholders confident in GM can stay put.

Some GM investors could even donate their profits to Harvard, where Warren’s husband, Bruce Mann, is paid $424,873 annually as a law professor. Warren herself previously taught at Harvard Law School.

GM went bankrupt in 2009 after a long decline, partly because its management did not pay enough attention to customers or shareholders. Politicians can attack corporate leaders for making too little money or, when profits reach shareholders, for making too much.

Warren’s office did not respond to an inquiry from the Washington Free Beacon. A GM spokesman defended the company’s priorities and emphasized its investment record since 2020.

"GM’s first priority is investing in our business and our employees. Since 2020, we’ve reinvested more than $100 billion to fund our growth, including in our products, our factories, and our people. The new repurchase authorization is a meaningful statement of confidence in GM’s ability to fund growth, reward our U.S. employees with the highest profit sharing in the industry, while also returning capital to our shareholder owners."

Politicians may prefer that GM spend its capital on higher worker pay or factories for electric cars. In a free enterprise economy, however, owners and the management they elect decide how private capital is allocated.

If Warren and El-Sayed believe they can allocate GM’s money better, they can buy shares and wage a proxy campaign. Throwing political weight around through threatening letters is better suited to countries with state owned automakers, including North Korea, Communist China, Russia, and Iran.

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content partners are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of BoredTrashPanda.com. Contact us for guidelines on submitting your own commentary.